Can a Sibling Contest a Will in Victoria?
23 June 2026When a brother or sister dies, inheritance questions can become complicated, especially if you have been excluded from their will or believe the estate was distributed unfairly.
One common question is whether a sibling can contest a will in Victoria.
In most circumstances, brothers and sisters do not have an automatic right to contest a sibling’s will for a greater share of the estate. However, a sibling may qualify to make a family provision claim in limited circumstances. You may also have separate legal grounds to challenge a will’s validity.
At Hentys Lawyers, our wills and estates lawyers help individuals understand their inheritance rights, assess potential estate claims, and resolve disputes involving deceased estates.
Can a Brother or Sister Contest a Will in Victoria?
Under the Administration and Probate Act 1958 (Vic), only certain eligible people can make a family provision claim against a deceased estate.
A family provision claim is an application seeking financial provision, or further provision, from an estate where an eligible person believes they have not been adequately provided for.
Unlike certain other family relationships, being the deceased’s brother or sister does not automatically establish eligibility.
This means a sibling generally cannot contest a will simply because:
- They were excluded from the will.
- Another sibling received a larger inheritance.
- They believe the deceased’s decision was unfair.
- They had a close relationship with the deceased.
- They expected to inherit part of the estate.
However, a sibling may have legal options depending on their living arrangements, financial dependency and the circumstances surrounding the will.
When Can a Sibling Make a Family Provision Claim?
Although siblings are not automatically eligible, they may qualify under another category recognised by Victorian legislation.
One potentially relevant category is someone who was a member of the deceased’s household and was wholly or partly dependent on the deceased for proper maintenance and support at the time of death.
For example, a brother or sister who lived with the deceased and relied on them for financial support may have grounds to investigate their eligibility.
Financial Dependency
Financial dependency can be an important consideration when determining whether a sibling qualifies to make a claim.
Relevant circumstances may include:
- The deceased regularly contributed towards the sibling’s living expenses.
- The sibling relied on the deceased for accommodation and financial support.
- The deceased helped pay for essential household expenses.
- The sibling was unable to support themselves independently.
- The sibling received ongoing financial assistance from the deceased.
However, financial assistance alone does not automatically establish eligibility.
The person’s relationship to the deceased, household membership and the specific statutory requirements must also be considered.
Living in the Same Household
A sibling who lived with the deceased may be eligible to make a family provision claim if they meet the relevant legal requirements.
For example, two adult siblings may have shared a home for many years, with one providing substantial financial support to the other.
If the will excludes the financially dependent sibling, there may be grounds to investigate whether they qualify as an eligible person.
However, simply living at the same address does not guarantee eligibility.
What Will the Court Consider?
If a sibling establishes eligibility, the court must consider whether the deceased had a moral duty to provide for their proper maintenance and support and whether they made adequate provision.
Depending on the circumstances, relevant factors may include:
- The nature and duration of the relationship.
- The extent of financial dependency.
- The sibling’s financial resources and needs.
- The size and nature of the deceased’s estate.
- The circumstances of other beneficiaries.
- Any relevant contributions made to the deceased’s welfare or estate.
- The deceased’s reasons for making particular provisions in the will.
Every estate is different, and eligibility does not guarantee a successful claim.
Can You Contest a Will if Your Brother or Sister Left You Nothing?
Being excluded from a sibling’s will can be upsetting, especially if you had a close relationship or expected to inherit.
However, being left out of a will does not automatically provide grounds to contest it.
In Victoria, individuals generally can decide how their estate will be distributed, subject to applicable legal obligations.
If your brother or sister left their estate to a spouse, children, another sibling, or an unrelated person, you can’t necessarily challenge that decision simply because you disagree with it.
The key questions are whether you qualify to make a family provision claim or whether you have legitimate grounds to challenge the will’s validity.
Contesting a Will vs Challenging a Will: What’s the Difference?
Although the terms are often used interchangeably, contesting a will and challenging a will can involve different legal processes.
Contesting a Will Through a Family Provision Claim
A family provision claim generally accepts that the will is valid but seeks provision or further provision from the estate.
Only people who satisfy the relevant eligibility requirements can bring this type of claim.
For siblings, this means establishing eligibility under a recognised statutory category rather than relying solely on their family relationship.
Learn more about family provision claims in Victoria.
Challenging the Validity of a Will
Challenging a will involves questioning whether the will is legally valid.
Depending on the circumstances, potential grounds may include:
Lack of Testamentary Capacity
The deceased may not have had the necessary mental capacity to understand the nature and effect of making their will.
Undue Influence
Evidence may show the deceased was coerced into making a will that did not reflect their independent wishes.
Fraud or Forgery
The will may have been affected by fraudulent conduct or a forged signature.
Improper Execution
The will may not have complied with the relevant legal formalities, although Victorian law allows some informal documents to be admitted as wills.
A Later Will Exists
A more recent valid will may have been discovered that changes or replaces the earlier document.
A sibling who has a genuine legal interest in the estate may be able to raise concerns about the will’s validity, even if they are not eligible to make a family provision claim.
However, the circumstances determine who can challenge a will and what evidence is required.
For more information, see our Challenging a Will service page.
Can a Sibling Inherit if there is no will in Victoria?
Yes. A brother or sister may be entitled to inherit from a deceased sibling who dies without a valid will, depending on which relatives survive them.
When someone dies without a valid will, Victoria’s intestacy laws distribute their estate.
The order of entitlement depends on the deceased’s surviving family relationships.
For example, if the deceased leaves no surviving partner, descendants or parents, surviving siblings may be entitled to share in the estate.
Where a sibling has died before the deceased, that sibling’s children may also have inheritance rights in certain circumstances.
However, siblings do not automatically inherit where closer relatives have priority under the intestacy rules.
The distribution depends on the deceased’s family circumstances and the applicable legislation.
If your brother or sister died without a will, our probate and estate lawyers can help you understand the estate administration process.
Can One Sibling Challenge Another Sibling’s Inheritance?
Disagreements can arise where one brother or sister receives a substantially larger inheritance than another.
For example, a deceased person may leave most of their estate to one sibling because that person provided care, financial assistance or support during their lifetime.
Another sibling may believe the arrangement is unfair.
However, an unequal inheritance does not automatically mean the will can be contested.
The person considering legal action must establish an appropriate legal basis for the claim.
This may involve establishing eligibility for a family provision claim or presenting evidence that raises concerns about the will’s validity.
Disputes may also arise over how an executor administers the estate, a separate issue from contesting the will itself.
What Evidence May Be Needed to Contest a Sibling’s Will?
The evidence required depends on the type of claim.
For a potential family provision claim involving household membership and financial dependency, relevant documents may include:
- Bank statements showing regular financial support.
- Evidence of shared accommodation.
- Household bills and living expense records.
- Documents relating to the sibling’s financial circumstances.
- Medical records relevant to support needs, where appropriate.
- Correspondence concerning financial arrangements.
- Information about the deceased’s estate and beneficiaries.
For a challenge to a will’s validity, you may need different evidence, including medical information, earlier wills, witness accounts, and documents relating to the preparation or signing of the will.
A wills and estates lawyer can help identify which evidence is relevant to your circumstances.
How Long Does a Sibling Have to Contest a Will in Victoria?
For an eligible person making a family provision claim, the general time limit in Victoria is six months from the date probate or letters of administration are granted.
This period does not necessarily begin on the date of death.
The court may allow an application outside the usual timeframe in limited circumstances, but it does not guarantee an extension. The distribution of estate assets can also affect the available options.
Different procedural requirements apply when challenging t wwill’s validity
If you are considering a claim, it is important to obtain legal advice promptly.
Read more about contesting a will in Victoria.
What Should You Do if You Believe Your Sibling’s Will Is Unfair?
If you have concerns about your brother’s or sister’s will, you can take several steps.
1. Obtain a Copy of the Will
Find out whether you are entitled to inspect the will, and request a copy from the person holding it.
Once probate has been granted, the will generally becomes part of the public probate record.
2. Understand Your Potential Entitlement
Consider whether you meet the requirements for a family provision claim or have a legitimate interest in challenging the will’s validity.
3. Gather Relevant Documents
Collect records that may help establish your relationship with the deceased, financial dependency or concerns about the will.
4. Confirm Whether Probate Has Been Granted
The date probate or letters of administration were granted is particularly important when assessing family provision time limits.
5. Seek Legal Advice
An experienced wills and estates lawyer can assess your circumstances and explain whether there are grounds to pursue a claim.
Taking action early may help preserve your legal options.
Frequently Asked Questions About Siblings Contesting a Will
Can a brother contest his sister’s will in Victoria?
A brother does not automatically have the right to make a family provision claim against his sister’s estate. He may qualify if he falls into another eligible category, such as being financially dependent on her and living in her household. There may also be separate grounds to challenge the will’s validity.
Can a sister contest her brother’s will?
A sister may be able to bring a claim if she satisfies the relevant eligibility requirements under Victorian law. Being the deceased’s sister, without more, is generally insufficient for a family provision claim.
Can an adult sibling contest a will?
An adult sibling may qualify in limited circumstances, including where the statutory requirements relating to household membership and financial dependency are satisfied. The specific facts must be assessed.
Can I contest my sibling’s will if I was financially dependent on them?
Possibly. Financial dependency may be relevant, particularly if you were also a member of the deceased’s household. However, dependency by itself does not automatically make a sibling eligible.
Can I contest my sibling’s will if we lived together?
Living together may be relevant to eligibility, but it is not enough on its own. The nature of the household arrangement and whether you were wholly or partly dependent on the deceased for proper maintenance and support may need to be considered.
Can I challenge my sibling’s will if I believe someone influenced them?
You may have grounds to challenge a will if there is evidence of undue influence, coercion, or another issue affecting its validity. Suspicion or disagreement alone is not sufficient.
Do siblings have equal inheritance rights in Victoria?
Not necessarily. A person making a valid will can generally choose to leave different amounts to different siblings. If someone dies without a valid will, the statutory intestacy rules determine who inherits and in what proportions.
Can a sibling contest a will after probate has been granted?
Potentially. An eligible person generally has six months from the grant of probate or letters of administration to commence a family provision claim. Challenges to validity involve different legal considerations and procedures.
Is it worth contesting a sibling’s will?
This depends on whether you have a legally recognised basis for the claim, the available evidence, the size of the estate, the likely costs, and the potential outcome. A lawyer can help assess these factors before you commence proceedings.
Speak With Our Wills and Estates Lawyers in Melbourne
Disputes involving a brother’s or sister’s estate can be legally complicated, particularly where questions arise about financial dependency, inheritance rights or the validity of a will.
At Hentys Lawyers, our Melbourne wills and estates lawyers ahelpclients iunderstandtheir legal position and aassesspotential estate disputes.
Whether you have been excluded from a sibling’s will, believe the will may be invalid, or need advice about your entitlement to an estate, our team can help you understand your options.
Contact Hentys Lawyers to discuss your circumstances and obtain advice about your inheritance rights.
Contact Our Wills and Estates Lawyers
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about Victorian wills and estates law and does not constitute legal advice. Eligibility, time limits and available legal remedies depend on individual circumstances.