Employee vs Independent Contractor: What Australian Employers Need to Know
19 October 2026Australian business owners know running a company comes with many choices, responsibilities, and risks. Like many employers in Australia, choosing to hire workers for their company as independent contractors, instead of employees, is a common choice. Although contracting arrangements can offer great flexibility for both the business owner and the contractor, misclassifying a worker can lead to serious legal and financial risks.
Although it may be a beneficial choice, it is crucial to understand that merely labelling someone as a contractor, asking them to acquire an ABN and having them sign a contractor agreement does not automatically define their legal status. The classification of a worker as either an employee or an independent contractor will depend on the nature of the relationship and the legal criteria applicable to that specific arrangement.
Recent changes to the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) have also altered the way employee and contractor status is assessed in certain circumstances, making it an extremely important task for employers to regularly review their workforce arrangements with their contractors.
What Is the Difference Between an Employee and an Independent Contractor?
In broad terms, when a person works within and as part of a business, this is where it can be classified as an employee. When a person operates their own business and provides services to a client, this can be described as a contractor.
It is important to remember that the distinction between the terms is not always clear. Many working arrangements contain characteristics of both employment and contracting relationships, which is why classification requires a careful assessment of the overall nature of the relationship.
Some factors commonly considered may include:
| Employee | Independent Contractor |
|---|---|
| Business exercises significant control over how work is performed | Greater independence in how work is performed |
| Usually required to perform work personally | May be able to delegate or subcontract work |
| Limited exposure to business risks | Bears commercial and financial risk |
| Employer often provides tools and equipment | Usually supplies own tools and equipment |
| Set work or directed hours | Greater flexibility with working hours |
| Ongoing expectation of work | Often engaged for a specific task or project |
| Usually paid wages or salary | Commonly paid by invoice or project |
| Receives leave and other employment entitlements | Generally responsible for own entitlements and insurances |
While these indicators can provide a snapshot of key differences, there isn’t a single factor that can determine the outcome. The legal character of the arrangement must be assessed as a whole.
How Do You Determine Whether Someone Is an Employee or Contractor?
Assessing whether a worker is an employee or independent contractor is not a simple task or standard checklist exercise.
Australia has significant workplace laws in place that require careful consideration of the legal rights and obligations between the two parties, together with the broader circumstances of the working relationship where relevant. A number of reasons that determine this may include the level of control exercised by the business, if the worker can delegate work, who provides the equipment, what degree of financial risk is present and the practical operation of the arrangement may all be important factors to consider.
The outcome will be influenced by the specific facts of the relationship, including the contractual terms and how the arrangement operates in practice.
For this reason, business owners should avoid heavily relying on assumptions or labels when engaging with workers.
The Whole of Relationship Test
Significant changes commenced on 26 August 2024 through amendments to the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).
Section 15AA was introduced to define the meaning of “employee” and “employer” under the Fair Work Act. For businesses and working relationships to which the provision applies, determining worker status now requires consideration of the “real substance, practical reality and true nature” of the relationship.
This method is commonly known as the whole of relationship test.
Under this test, the evaluation goes beyond the written contract and may take into account the overall relationship between the parties. This includes examining how the arrangement is actually performed in practice. In more simpler terms, the day-to-day reality of the working relationship may have some relevance when determining whether a worker is truly operating as an independent contractor or is functioning as an employee.
More importantly, the applicable test can depend on the type of business and working arrangement involved. It is vital for employers to obtain advice where there may be uncertainty about the correct classification of workers.
It is important to highlight that some contractors, such as specific employee-like digital platform workers and road transport contractors, now benefit from additional protections under the Fair Work framework.
Does Having an ABN Make Someone an Independent Contractor?
One of the most common misconceptions among business owners and employers is that if a worker has an ABN they automatically become an independent contractor – and this is simply not the case.
In a similar assumption, whether it be submitting invoices, entering into a contractor agreement or describing a worker as a contractor will also not necessarily determine the legal nature of the relationship.
While these are definitely relevant factors, they are not a conclusive answer. A worker may still be found to be an employee if the overall relationship indicates that a certain employment arrangement exists.
Businesses should therefore be focusing on the nature of the relationship rather than the labels used by each parties.
What Is Sham Contracting?
Broadly speaking, sham contracting takes place when an employer misrepresents an employment relationship as an independent contracting arrangement, even though that characterization is not legally accurate.
The Fair Work Act contains provisions that prohibit sham contracting arrangements.
Sections 357 to 359 of the Fair Work Act prohibit conduct such as misrepresenting an employment relationship as an independent contracting arrangement, dismissing an employee to engage them as a contractor or making false statements to persuade a worker to become an independent contractor.
Business owners should also be aware that penalties may apply where these provisions are breached. While the legislation includes a reasonable belief defence in certain circumstances, employers should be careful about relying on assumptions regarding worker classification.
What Happens if a Contractor Is Actually an Employee?
When a worker initially classified as a contractor is later found to be an employee, the consequences can be significant.
Depending on different circumstances, a business may become liable for unpaid employee entitlements such as annual leave, personal leave, public holiday entitlements, notice of termination and other workplace benefits.
There could also be exposure concerning unpaid superannuation contributions, PAYG withholding obligations, and various taxation-related liabilities.
In addition to these issues, employers may face Fair Work claims and civil penalties that arise with failure to comply with workplace laws.
The longer an incorrectly classified arrangement has been in place, the greater the potential financial cost may be.
Reviewing Your Contractor Arrangements
Employers should regularly review contractor agreements to ensure they continue to reflect the reality of the working relationship.
A review may be appropriate where contractors work exclusively or predominantly for the employer, where arrangements have continued to develop over time, or where the business exercises significant control over how work is performed.
It is common for working relationships to change and pivot as a business grows with increasing demand. An arrangement that initially operated as genuine contracting may gradually take on characteristics more consistent with employment.
This is why regular reviews of both contractual documentation and day-to-day practices can assist in identifying potential risks before disputes arise.
Getting Legal Advice About Employee and Contractor Classification
Correctly determining whether a person is an employee or an independent contractor requires careful consideration of the applicable legal test, the contractual arrangements and the practical reality of the ever changing relationship.
If you engage contractors and are unclear whether your arrangements remain compliant, obtaining legal advice can help minimise risk and avoid costly disputes with significant consequences.
At Hentys Lawyers, we provide professional advice for businesses on employee and contractor classification, workplace compliance and contractor arrangements. If you are in need of advice regarding your workforce structure or would like existing contractor arrangements reviewed, contact our employment law team at Hentys Lawyers.