When Should an Employer Conduct a Workplace Investigation?
28 January 2025Workplace complaints, allegations of employee misconduct and internal disputes can create major legal and operational risks for Australian employers. Knowing when to conduct a workplace investigation is an important part of responding appropriately to these concerns whilst maintaining a safe, fair and legally compliant workplace.
Not every employee complaint requires a formal investigation. However, where allegations involve serious misconduct, workplace bullying, sexual harassment, discrimination or possible breaches of workplace law, employers may need to undertake a structured fact-finding process before deciding what action to take.
At Hentys Lawyers, we assist employers, business owners and HR teams across Melbourne and Australia in assessing workplace complaints, determining whether an investigation is necessary and directing complex employment matters.
When Is a Workplace Investigation Necessary?
An employer should consider a workplace investigation when allegations are sufficiently serious, the relevant facts are disputed, or a fair and impartial assessment is needed before making disciplinary or other employment decisions.
A formal investigation may be appropriate where:
- An employee makes a serious complaint about another employee or manager.
- Allegations involve bullying, harassment or discrimination.
- Suspected misconduct could result in disciplinary action or termination.
- Workplace safety concerns entail further examination.
- Multiple employees provide conflicting accounts of an incident.
- Allegations of fraud, theft, or breaches of company policies.
- An employee raises issues about retaliation or victimisation.
- A complaint involves senior management or a potential conflict of interest.
The decision should reflect the seriousness of the allegations, the available evidence, the employer’s legal obligations as well as the potential consequences for those involved.
Employers should also consider whether an independent workplace investigation is appropriate, particularly where impartiality or process-related fairness may be questioned.
What Types of Workplace Complaints May Require an Investigation?
Certain workplace complaints carry heightened legal, reputational or safety risks and may require a more formal response.
Workplace Bullying and Harassment
Promptly assess allegations of repeated unreasonable behaviour, intimidation, harassment, or inappropriate workplace conduct.
Employers must manage workplace health and safety risks, including psychosocial hazards. Where allegations are disputed or sufficiently serious, a workplace investigation may help establish what occurred and what corrective action is appropriate.
Sexual Harassment and Discrimination
Complaints involving sexual harassment, discrimination or victimisation entail careful handling.
Employers must consider their obligations under applicable anti-discrimination legislation, including the positive duty under federal sex discrimination law to take reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate certain unlawful conduct as far as possible.
An investigation may be necessary to establish the facts, assess the allegations and inform an appropriate response. Employers should also consider immediate protective measures as addressing a complaint.
Employee Misconduct
Suspected employee misconduct may involve dishonesty, inappropriate behaviour, breaches of workplace policies, unauthorised disclosure of confidential information or failure to follow reasonable workplace directions.
Where misconduct allegations could lead to disciplinary action or dismissal, employers should establish the relevant facts and provide procedural fairness before making a decision.
Fraud, Theft and Serious Policy Breaches
Allegations involving fraud, theft, conflicts of interest or misuse of company resources may require a structured investigation to preserve evidence, establish accountability and determine whether further legal or regulatory action is necessary.
Depending on the circumstances, employers may also need to consider reporting obligations or specialist legal advice.
Does Every Employee Complaint Require a Formal Workplace Investigation?
No. Not every workplace complaint warrants a formal investigation.
Some concerns can be addressed through informal discussions, management intervention, clarification of workplace expectations or an appropriate dispute resolution process.
For example, a minor disagreement between colleagues may be resolved through a facilitated conversation, provided no underlying allegations require a more formal response.
However, employers should avoid dismissing complaints simply because they appear minor or because an employee has not submitted a formal written grievance.
Before determining the appropriate response, employers should consider:
- Seriousness: Does the complaint involve alleged unlawful conduct, serious misconduct or a safety risk?
- Evidence: Are the relevant facts disputed or unclear?
- Potential consequences: Could the allegations lead to disciplinary action, dismissal or legal proceedings?
- Workplace policies: Do internal procedures require a particular investigation or complaint-handling process?
- Impartiality: Can the matter be assessed fairly by someone within the organisation?
- Ongoing risk: Is there a risk of further harm, retaliation or escalation?
A proportionate response is important. The objective is not necessarily to investigate every disagreement formally, but to ensure complaints are assessed and addressed appropriately.
When Should an Employer Engage an Independent Workplace Investigator?
An independent workplace investigator may be appropriate when internal management or HR personnel cannot reasonably conduct an impartial investigation, or where the allegations present major legal or organisational risks.
Employers should consider external assistance when:
- The complaint involves a director, executive or senior manager.
- The allegations involve members of the HR team.
- Multiple employees or departments are involved.
- The allegations concern serious harassment, discrimination or misconduct.
- Internal relationships could create actual or perceived conflicts of interest.
- The matter may result in litigation, regulatory scrutiny or significant disciplinary consequences.
- The organisation lacks the internal resources or experience required to investigate the matter.
An external investigator can independently assess the evidence, conduct interviews, and prepare findings based on the applicable standard of proof.
Hentys Lawyers provides independent workplace investigation services for employers managing sensitive, complex or high-risk workplace matters.
What Should Employers Do Before Starting a Workplace Investigation?
Before commencing a formal workplace investigation, employers should carefully assess the complaint and establish an appropriate process.
1. Assess the Complaint and Immediate Risks
Determine the nature of the allegations, whether immediate safety measures are required, and whether any urgent reporting or compliance obligations apply.
Temporary workplace arrangements may be appropriate in some circumstances, but employers should avoid measures that unnecessarily disadvantage the complainant or prejudge the outcome.
2. Preserve Relevant Evidence
Employers should identify and preserve potentially relevant information, including emails, messages, documents, CCTV footage, workplace records and other available evidence.
Handle evidence lawfully, securely, and in accordance with appropriate privacy and workplace requirements.
3. Determine the Scope of the Investigation
The investigation should have clearly defined allegations and terms of reference.
Establishing the scope early helps prevent unnecessary expansion and keeps the process focused on the matters requiring determination.
4. Appoint an Appropriate Investigator
Consider whether the investigation can be conducted internally or whether an independent investigator is required.
The investigator should have appropriate experience, understand procedural fairness and be free from conflicts of interest.
5. Consider Legal Advice
Where allegations could result in dismissal, litigation, regulatory action or other significant consequences, employers should consider obtaining legal advice before commencing the investigation.
Hentys Lawyers provides employment law advice for employers dealing with workplace misconduct, disciplinary matters and complex employee complaints.
What Happens If an Employer Fails to Investigate a Serious Workplace Complaint?
Failing to respond appropriately to a serious workplace complaint can expose an employer to major legal and operational consequences.
Depending on the circumstances, these may include:
- Unfair dismissal or general protections claims arising from poorly managed disciplinary decisions.
- Discrimination, sexual harassment or victimisation complaints.
- Workplace health and safety investigations or regulatory action.
- Increased workplace conflict, absenteeism and employee turnover.
- Reputational damage and loss of employee confidence.
- Challenges to disciplinary decisions where allegations were not properly examined.
Importantly, an employer’s obligations depend on the nature of the complaint and the applicable law. A formal investigation is not automatically required in every case, but employers must still take appropriate steps to address identified risks and comply with their legal responsibilities.
How Can Employers Ensure Procedural Fairness During an Investigation?
Procedural fairness is an important consideration when investigating employee misconduct, particularly where the findings may lead to disciplinary action or dismissal.
A fair investigation generally involves:
- Clearly identifying the allegations being investigated.
- Giving the employee a reasonable opportunity to respond to allegations that may be relied upon.
- Considering relevant evidence objectively.
- Avoiding predetermined conclusions.
- Managing actual or perceived conflicts of interest.
- Maintaining confidentiality as far as reasonably practicable.
- Documenting the investigation process and findings.
Employers should also distinguish between establishing whether allegations are substantiated and deciding what disciplinary or management action should follow.
A substantiated allegation does not automatically justify dismissal. Assess any proposed action against the seriousness of the conduct, the employee’s circumstances, applicable employment obligations, and the available evidence.
When Should Employers Seek Legal Advice About a Workplace Investigation?
Employers should consider seeking legal advice early when workplace complaints involve serious misconduct, complex legal obligations or potential disciplinary consequences.
Early advice may be particularly valuable where allegations involve senior employees, sexual harassment, discrimination, whistleblower complaints, suspected fraud or potential termination of employment.
Legal guidance can help employers determine whether an investigation is necessary, identify the appropriate process, understand their obligations and reduce the risk of procedural mistakes.
Hentys Lawyers assists employers across Melbourne and Australia with workplace investigations, employment disputes, disciplinary processes and related workplace law matters.
Our employer-focused approach fuses practical legal advice with an understanding of the commercial and operational challenges businesses face when managing delicate employee complaints.
Speak With Hentys Lawyers About Workplace Investigations
If your business has received a serious employee complaint or is considering disciplinary action after allegations of misconduct, early advice can help ensure the matter is handled appropriately.
Hentys Lawyers provides independent workplace investigations and employment law support for employers across Australia.
Explore Our Workplace Investigation Services or Contact Hentys Lawyers to discuss your circumstances.